Joey Fatone and Lance Bass reunited to perform *NSYNC's "It's Gonna Be Me" during a post-show sing-along at & Juliet
NEED TO KNOW
-
Lance Bass surprised the audience by running from Titanique, narrowly making it on stage in time
-
Joey Fatone has a history with Broadway and & Juliet, previously starring in the musical and co-producing Titanique
It was the year 2000 all over again at the Stephen Sondheim Theatre on Tuesday, May 12, asJoey FatoneandLance Bassreunited to perform *NSYNC's No. 1 hit "It's Gonna Be Me" for a crowd of cheering fans.
The special moment was a part of a month-long celebration Broadway's& Julietis throwing in celebration of the song, which has become a meme over the years on social media as a way to mark the beginning of May thanks toJustin Timberlake's pronunciation of the word "Me."
Areference to the joke is even made in the musical, which is set to a score of others songs by hitmaker Max Martin including “Since U Been Gone,” “Roar,” “Baby One More Time,” “Larger Than Life,” “That’s The Way It Is,” “Can’t Stop the Feeling" and more.
Tuesday's performance of the song by Fatone and Bass nearly didn't happen, however.
Theatergoers knew Fatone was leading the post-show sing-along, his role as host announced when the event was revealed earlier this month. But Bass had previous plans on the books, with tickets to see another Broadway hit — the hilarious Tony Award-nominated Best MusicalTitanique— across the way.
Turns out,Titanique's90-minute runtime worked to Bass' advantage. He ran through Times Square from the St. James Theatre, making it on stage just in time to surprise Fatone and the& Julietaudience.
"He made it! He made it!" Fatone cheered, in video of the moment shared by& Juliet's Instagram page.
“I almost got hit by six taxicabs, but I made it by the last note!" said Bass.
Fatone, 49, is no stranger to& Juliet. The singer and actor perviously starred in the musical as Lance, both on Broadway and during a recent stint on the tour's stop in Orlando, Florida.
He's also no stranger to Broadway, with roles inLittle Shop of HorrorsandRentthroughout his career. He's even a co-producer onTitaniquethis season, with his other *NSYNC bandmate,JC Chasez.
Advertisement
Bass, 47, has a Broadway acting credit of his own, too. He previously played Link Larkin during the run ofHairspray.
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE's free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Meanwhile, *NSYNC fans will get more opportunities to see Fatone and Bass together soon.
The two are hosting a new mixology competition series namedCocktail Wars, which will premiered this summer on Versant-owned network E!
Announced this week at the NBCUniversal Upfronts, the 10-part series will see bartenders go head-to-head in a high-stakes cocktail competition, where creativity, precision and taste will determine who takes home a $10,000 prize each week. Competitors will be judged by various celebrities and an expert judge.
“We’re excited to be part ofCocktail Warsand team up again for something this fun,” said Bass and Fatone in a statement. “With this much talent, a little competition, a lot of cocktails and just enough chaos to keep things interesting — that’s usually where we thrive.”
As for "It's Gonna Be May,"Fatone and Bass have previously opened up about the song's unique legacy.
"I mean, it is crazy. If you want to stay relevant, become a meme for the young kids out there," Bass told PEOPLE in 2025. "It's something that fans get to have fun with every single year. It keeps the song kind of in people's minds, which is nice. It keeps us alive every year. It’s the most searched *NSYNC thing ever on that day just because of this stupid little meme, which I’m sure Justin loved. But yeah, it's a gift that keeps on giving."
"There are so many different ones out there," Fatone added. "And I think, again, like Lance was saying, people just get creative. The more the years go on, the more variations you see — including old-school stuff they’re digging up — and then they put the words under the meme. It’s hilarious. I think it’s great. Again, why not? Why not run with it? It’s fun."
Tickets to& Julietare now on sale.
Read the original article onPeople